Skip to main content

The Republic? More like the Communist Manifesto // Braylan Stringfellow

     Arguably the worst thing to happen in recent human history is the rise of Communism. No knows exactly how many people have died from Communism, but it has been estimated that it is way over 100 million. All throughout book III, I see communistic tendencies in this "city" that Socrates wants. 

    First off, there is no freedom of choice in career paths for the citizens. The government decides what the citizens can do based off there skill set. They are not allowed to do anything they want to do. Second the government decides what the people learn. Right on the first page of book three, Socrates said, "What about any man who believes the underworld is real and terrible? Will he be fearless? In battle, will he prefer death to defeat and slavery?" (Plato 82). He then says that these passages describing how terrible Hades is must be banned so that the soldiers will not be scared of death. He says needs to be done to other areas like the gods and heros. The passages describing how terrible they are must be removed. Socrates wants this done because he has a preconceived idea on how these things should be. Thirdly, the government decides what people can write and how they write it. This means no freedom of the press. 

    What Socrates is creating is a communist dictatorship. The government takes the place of god and it can do whatever it wants to. This quote sums it up best: "Now if the ruler of a city catches anybody lying--besides himself. . . he will punish them for subversive practice" (86). Notice he said "besides himself." This is exactly how the dictators of communist countries work. They are there own gods.

I commented on Lily Caswell's and Haylee Lynd's post

Comments

  1. Abigale BellSeptember 28, 2020 at 10:28 PM

    Hi Braylan! I enjoyed reading your post. You have an interesting take on the ideas Socrates brought to light. I think, in his vision, the laws were perfect in that they were all for the good of the people. The leaders would have been brought up from childhood to know the laws and to fulfill them. The laws themselves are what take on the deistic role. I agree, though, that this whole picture is very similar to that of a communist governement.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Lily CaswellSeptember 28, 2020 at 10:42 PM

    I actually did not think about Socrates’ city being like a Communist dictatorship but it really makes a lot of sense. Everyone does one individual thing so the whole community thrives, which is extremely similar to Communist countries. Very nice post, Braylan.

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Oedipus’ Children/Siblings—Lily Caswell

Ok, so Oedipus is a bit of a train wreck to say the least. I love the fact that even after Oedipus found out about his less-than-appealing relationship with his mother, he still tried to look after his children/siblings. After he gouged his eyes out, his children came to him at which point Oedipus talked about how that when they were old enough to marry, no one would want them due to them being products of incest. He said for the people not to condemn them based on what their father had done. Even after he knew what he had done and what his children were, he still wanted the best for them. I commented on Logan’s and Ian’s posts.
3 comments
Read more

Aristotle Might Not Like Me...Or Jesus//Haylee Lynd

      Aristotle says that the man who does not get angry at the things he should be angry at "is thought unlikely to defend himself; and to endure being insulted and put up with insult to one's friends is slavish" (Aristotle 41). While he states that passivity is preferred to excessive anger, he still gives great criticism to it.  In contrast to Aristotle, the man who Christians believe to be the most just is Jesus who states in Matthew 5:39-40, "...do not resist an evil person. If anyone slaps you on the right cheek, turn to them the other also. And if anyone wants to sue you and take your shirt, hand over your coat as well." Essentially, arguing that one is not to respond in anger when insulted or hurt, to not defend one's self. Most individual's are unable to achieve this. Our natural instinct is to defend ourselves, especially in physical cases. However, Christians strive to be like Jesus in this way. I would also argue that it is a very admirable wa...
2 comments
Read more

One shall stand, One shall fall // Ian Blair

      I usually have a little introduction into my thoughts about the reading for this week before I start with the actual blog part of my post, but I can't help but think about the bone-chilling realization that awaits us in Book VIII, so my introduction this time will be brief. It is my personal opinion that if people are imperfect, then we are only capable of imperfect systems and societies consequentially. However, this does not mean that we must not aim for the closest system to perfect that we can achieve.      The realization I wrote of earlier is the suggestion by Socrates that tyranny stems from the system we know as democracy. At first I disagreed, it is anarchism that causes  tyrannical reign as a byproduct of fulfilling its purpose of overthrowing the current power and not establishing another system. All anarchism does is create a power vacuum for another power to take over and the cycle repeats itself, right? ...Right? Quic...
1 comment
Read more